Where's the other half of Mount Elbert? :-)

Colorado peak questions, condition requests and other info.
Forum rules
  • This is a mountaineering forum, so please keep your posts on-topic. Posts do not all have to be related to the 14ers but should at least be mountaineering-related.
  • Personal attacks and confrontational behavior will result in removal from the forum at the discretion of the administrators.
  • Do not use this forum to advertise, sell photos or other products or promote a commercial website.
  • Posts will be removed at the discretion of the site administrator or moderator(s), including: Troll posts, posts pushing political views or religious beliefs, and posts with the purpose of instigating conflict within the forum.
    For more details, please see the Terms of Use you agreed to when joining the forum.
User avatar
mgl45
Posts: 158
Joined: 6/27/2021
14ers: 1 
13ers: 1
Trip Reports (0)
 

Where's the other half of Mount Elbert? :-)

Post by mgl45 »

I stumbled across somewhat of a mystery (possibly).

There seem to be 3 sources which state the prominence of Mount Elbert and they all say it's over 9k feet.

Source #1
https://www.peakbagger.com/peak.aspx?pid=5736

Source #2
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_t ... ted_States

Source #3
Google "What is the prominence of Mount Elbert" and Google reports the answer at the top of the search results. I think Google might be pulling this info from one of the other sources.

I notice this long ago and it never quite passed the smell test to me since the nearby towns pretty high up - Leadville 10k'+, Twin Lakes ~9,600', Aspen ~8000'.

Today I took a close look at the topo map on Alltrails.com and the lowest the elevation around Elbert drops before rising up to another peak is ~9700', near Highway 24, which seems like it would give Elbert a prominence of 4700'
https://www.alltrails.com/explore/trail ... static-map

What do you guys think? Are the sources that say 9k+ prominence possibly wrong or am I maybe misunderstanding some subtly to how prominence is measured? I love to do mountain research though and I am an out-of-state newbie.

I've been thinking about this now, in part, because I just saw Elbert for the first time from Leadville earlier this week and tomorrow and am planning on driving Independence pass, and if there is some place to see Elbert standing up 9000'+ feet from the surrounding terrain, while I'm in the area I've love to see it! :-)

Thanks much for any thoughts anyone has.
User avatar
BillMiddlebrook
Site Administrator
Posts: 6910
Joined: 7/25/2004
14ers: 58  46  19 
13ers: 172 44 37
Trip Reports (2)
 
Contact:

Re: Where's the other half of Mount Elbert? :-)

Post by BillMiddlebrook »

Are you familiar with Mt. Whitney?
"When I go out, I become more alive. I just love skiing. The gravitational pull. When you ski steep terrain... you can almost get a feeling of flying." -Doug Coombs
LarryM
Posts: 397
Joined: 5/11/2008
14ers: 27 
13ers: 32
Trip Reports (3)
 

Re: Where's the other half of Mount Elbert? :-)

Post by LarryM »

"Prominence is calculated as the difference in elevation between a summit and the highest saddle that connects that summit to any higher terrain. ... Put another way, prominence is the elevation difference between the summit and the lowest contour that encircles it and no higher summit."

I'm curious where the "saddle" is ... I'd guess somewhere in Wyoming maybe?
User avatar
mgl45
Posts: 158
Joined: 6/27/2021
14ers: 1 
13ers: 1
Trip Reports (0)
 

Re: Where's the other half of Mount Elbert? :-)

Post by mgl45 »

BillMiddlebrook wrote: Wed Sep 15, 2021 8:05 pm Are you familiar with Mt. Whitney?
Somewhat, yes, though I've never studied its prominence.
User avatar
mgl45
Posts: 158
Joined: 6/27/2021
14ers: 1 
13ers: 1
Trip Reports (0)
 

Re: Where's the other half of Mount Elbert? :-)

Post by mgl45 »

LarryM wrote: Wed Sep 15, 2021 8:09 pm "Prominence is calculated as the difference in elevation between a summit and the highest saddle that connects that summit to any higher terrain. ... Put another way, prominence is the elevation difference between the summit and the lowest contour that encircles it and no higher summit."

I'm curious where the "saddle" is ... I'd guess somewhere in Wyoming maybe?

Thanks!

That's a more comprehensive definition of prominence that I could find. If I understand it correctly, for Elbert to have 9,000'+ of prominence, there should be a saddle ~5400 feet in the vicinity.

I see lots of peaks on the topographical map around Mt. Elbert, like Bull Hill, Mt. Cosgriff, Monitor Rock, French Mountain, Casco Peak, Mount Oklahoma, Bald Eagle Mountain, Twin Mounds, South Peak, Empire Hill, Rocky Point, Black Mountain, and no saddle anywhere close to 5400 that I can see.

I agree, the saddle would need to be someplace like Wyoming to get to a 9,000 prominence, I'm just not seeing how to get there when Elbert is surrounded by other peaks. The neighboring peaks to the north and east seem relatively far away from Elbert compared to the west/south neighbors but they still block the way to any elevation anywhere close to 5,400 as far as I can see.
User avatar
IntrepidXJ
Posts: 380
Joined: 4/24/2008
14ers: 34 
13ers: 63
Trip Reports (90)
 
Contact:

Re: Where's the other half of Mount Elbert? :-)

Post by IntrepidXJ »

There's some good info in this thread with links about prominence: https://14ers.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=54079

According to that thread, the saddle that Mount Elbert's prominence is measured from to Mount Whitney is in California at 5340ft here: https://listsofjohn.com/qmap?lat=37.382 ... .8322&z=15
Randy Langstraat | ADVENTR.co
User avatar
IntrepidXJ
Posts: 380
Joined: 4/24/2008
14ers: 34 
13ers: 63
Trip Reports (90)
 
Contact:

Re: Where's the other half of Mount Elbert? :-)

Post by IntrepidXJ »

mgl45 wrote: Wed Sep 15, 2021 8:34 pm
I agree, the saddle would need to be someplace like Wyoming to get to a 9,000 prominence, I'm just not seeing how to get there when Elbert is surrounded by other peaks. The neighboring peaks to the north and east seem relatively far away from Elbert compared to the west/south neighbors but they still block the way to any elevation anywhere close to 5,400 as far as I can see.
Those surrounding peaks are not higher than Elbert. Prominence is measured to the saddle with the next highest peak, which for Elbert is Mount Whitney in California.
Randy Langstraat | ADVENTR.co
Ptglhs
Posts: 1478
Joined: 1/6/2016
14ers: 58  8 
13ers: 86 3
Trip Reports (4)
 

Re: Where's the other half of Mount Elbert? :-)

Post by Ptglhs »

It's this definition which makes prominence a worthless stat imo. If you're comparing it to a mountain thousands of miles away the prominence piece is academic.
User avatar
Scott P
Posts: 9438
Joined: 5/4/2005
14ers: 58  16 
13ers: 50 13
Trip Reports (16)
 
Contact:

Re: Where's the other half of Mount Elbert? :-)

Post by Scott P »

mgl45 wrote: Wed Sep 15, 2021 8:34 pmI'm curious where the "saddle" is ... I'd guess somewhere in Wyoming maybe?
It's in California, not Wyoming.
I'm old, slow and fat. Unfortunately, those are my good qualities.
User avatar
Scott P
Posts: 9438
Joined: 5/4/2005
14ers: 58  16 
13ers: 50 13
Trip Reports (16)
 
Contact:

Re: Where's the other half of Mount Elbert? :-)

Post by Scott P »

Ptglhs wrote: Wed Sep 15, 2021 8:39 pm It's this definition which makes prominence a worthless stat imo.
Personally, I both agree and disagree. It is useful in determining which peaks should be ranked. Other than that, it's not very useful in my opinion.
Last edited by Scott P on Wed Sep 15, 2021 8:49 pm, edited 1 time in total.
I'm old, slow and fat. Unfortunately, those are my good qualities.
User avatar
mgl45
Posts: 158
Joined: 6/27/2021
14ers: 1 
13ers: 1
Trip Reports (0)
 

Re: Where's the other half of Mount Elbert? :-)

Post by mgl45 »

IntrepidXJ wrote: Wed Sep 15, 2021 8:36 pm
mgl45 wrote: Wed Sep 15, 2021 8:34 pm
I agree, the saddle would need to be someplace like Wyoming to get to a 9,000 prominence, I'm just not seeing how to get there when Elbert is surrounded by other peaks. The neighboring peaks to the north and east seem relatively far away from Elbert compared to the west/south neighbors but they still block the way to any elevation anywhere close to 5,400 as far as I can see.
Those surrounding peaks are not higher than Elbert. Prominence is measured to the saddle with the next highest peak, which for Elbert is Mount Whitney in California.
Ah, there's the rub. It all makes sense now. Thanks for the information!
User avatar
mgl45
Posts: 158
Joined: 6/27/2021
14ers: 1 
13ers: 1
Trip Reports (0)
 

Re: Where's the other half of Mount Elbert? :-)

Post by mgl45 »

IntrepidXJ wrote: Wed Sep 15, 2021 8:34 pm There's some good info in this thread with links about prominence: https://14ers.com/forum/viewtopic.php?t=54079

According to that thread, the saddle that Mount Elbert's prominence is measured from to Mount Whitney is in California at 5340ft here: https://listsofjohn.com/qmap?lat=37.382 ... .8322&z=15
Interesting thread, thanks!
Post Reply